📦

审计历史

subagent-driven-development - 9 审计

版本对比

各审计版本间的能力与发现变化,最新在前。

版本日期结果复核项相对上一版变化
v9 最新2026年7月23日 16:35 1 已确认0能力无变化
v8 2026年7月10日 13:30 1 已确认0能力无变化
v7 2026年7月5日 10:30 无已确认发现0能力无变化
v6 2026年6月29日 15:21 无已确认发现3能力无变化
v5 2026年1月17日 02:55 无已确认发现0能力无变化
v4 2026年1月17日 02:55 无已确认发现0外部命令文件系统访问
v3 2026年1月7日 01:33 无已确认发现0能力无变化
v2 2026年1月7日 01:33 无已确认发现0能力无变化
v1 2026年1月7日 01:33 无已确认发现0基线

2026年7月23日 16:35

All 25 static alerts are false positives caused by Markdown fences, file references, review questions, and a quoted configuration path. The skill does direct implementers to modify, test, and commit code, creating an operational risk that requires scoped permissions and approval.

4
已扫描文件
403
分析行数
3
复核项
0
已忽略误报

已确认安全问题 (1)

中
Automated Repository Modification and Commit Workflow
The workflow directs implementer subagents to edit code, run tests, and commit changes. These actions can alter repositories without a pre-commit approval checkpoint.
Both files explicitly assign implementation, testing, and commit duties before review. This is intended functionality, but it creates a clear repository integrity risk.
审计者: codex

2026年7月10日 13:30

All 25 static findings are false positives caused by Markdown fences, inline paths, examples, and review checklists. The skill does direct implementer subagents to commit repository changes without explicit confirmation, creating a medium-impact side effect. No prompt injection, network reconnaissance, command execution, or home-directory access was found.

4
已扫描文件
403
分析行数
3
复核项
0
已忽略误报

已确认安全问题 (1)

中
Unconfirmed Repository Commit
The implementer prompt requires "Commit your work" without a user approval gate. This can create persistent repository history beyond the requested code changes.
The commit instruction is an explicit mandatory workflow step. No nearby instruction requires user confirmation before creating the commit.
审计者: codex

2026年7月5日 10:30

The static findings are false positives from Markdown code fences, prompt-template checklists, and an illustrative hidden-directory path. I found no evidence of command execution, filesystem access, network reconnaissance, or prompt injection intent in the cited files. No semantic findings were added because the content is workflow guidance rather than executable code.

4
已扫描文件
403
分析行数
2
复核项
0
已忽略误报
审计者: codex

2026年6月29日 15:21

AI review dismissed the high static hits as false positives caused by Markdown prompt templates, SHA labels, and checklist wording. The skill contains no executable scripts or network calls, but its intended workflow directs agents to inspect repository files, implement changes, and commit work. Publish with a warning for use only on trusted plans and repositories.

4
已扫描文件
403
分析行数
5
复核项
2
已忽略误报
能力复核项 (3)

这些是真实的本地能力,对此技能可能是预期行为,因此需要复核,但不会按已确认恶意行为计分。

中
Agent Workflow Can Modify and Commit Repository Code
The workflow instructs implementer subagents to implement task requirements, write tests, verify behavior, and commit their work. This is expected for the skill, but it creates elevated risk when used with untrusted plans or repositories.
The cited lines directly instruct implementation, testing, fixing, and committing. This is legitimate workflow behavior, so the concern is operational risk rather than malicious intent.
中
Reviewer Subagents Inspect Repository Contents
Reviewer templates tell subagents to read actual code and compare implementation details with requirements. This filesystem access is necessary for review, but repository contents may include sensitive or private files.
The file-reading behavior is explicit and central to the review workflow. The risk depends on repository sensitivity, so confidence is high for access scope but lower for harm.
低
Home Directory Path Is an Example, Not Hidden File Abuse
The ~/.config/superpowers/hooks/ path appears in an example answer about user-level hook installation. It does not read, write, or conceal data by itself, but hook-related plans should still be reviewed before execution.
The path is inside an example conversation and not part of executable code. The only residual concern is that future hook-installation tasks can affect user configuration.
已忽略静态误报 (2)

这些静态命中已被语义复核判定为误报,或只命中了 schema 定义里的词;这里保留展示用于透明度,但不影响质量评分。

低
Markdown Fence and Weak Crypto Matches Are False Positives
The reported Ruby backtick and weak crypto hits occur in Markdown fences, prompt labels, or SHA placeholders used for code review context. No executable Ruby, shell backtick execution, or cryptographic implementation was found.
The cited content is Markdown documentation and prompt template text, not executable code. The weak crypto hits align with words such as DESCRIPTION or SHA labels, not crypto logic.
低
Reconnaissance Matches Are Review Checklist False Positives
The system and network reconnaissance hits are questions about completeness, overbuilding, and code inspection. They do not instruct host enumeration, scanning, or network probing.
The surrounding text is a code review checklist. No commands, network targets, or host discovery actions are present in the cited lines.
审计者: codex

2026年1月17日 02:55

Pure prompt-based workflow orchestration skill containing only markdown documentation and AI agent templates. No executable code, scripts, network calls, or file system access. All static findings are false positives: markdown code blocks misclassified as shell execution, Git terminology flagged as crypto, and code review questions flagged as reconnaissance.

5
已扫描文件
603
分析行数
2
复核项
0
已忽略误报
审计者: claude

2026年1月17日 02:55

Pure prompt-based workflow orchestration skill containing only markdown documentation and AI agent templates. No executable code, scripts, network calls, or file system access. All static findings are false positives: markdown code blocks misclassified as shell execution, Git terminology flagged as crypto, and code review questions flagged as reconnaissance.

5
已扫描文件
603
分析行数
2
复核项
0
已忽略误报
审计者: claude

2026年1月7日 01:33

Pure prompt-based skill containing only markdown documentation and AI agent templates. No executable code, scripts, network calls, or file system access. All files are workflow orchestration prompts for AI subagents.

4
已扫描文件
380
分析行数
0
复核项
0
已忽略误报
此次已完成的审计未记录已确认的安全发现。
审计者: claude

2026年1月7日 01:33

Pure prompt-based skill containing only markdown documentation and AI agent templates. No executable code, scripts, network calls, or file system access. All files are workflow orchestration prompts for AI subagents.

4
已扫描文件
380
分析行数
0
复核项
0
已忽略误报
此次已完成的审计未记录已确认的安全发现。
审计者: claude

2026年1月7日 01:33

Pure prompt-based skill containing only markdown documentation and AI agent templates. No executable code, scripts, network calls, or file system access. All files are workflow orchestration prompts for AI subagents.

4
已扫描文件
380
分析行数
0
复核项
0
已忽略误报
此次已完成的审计未记录已确认的安全发现。
审计者: claude