Skills judgment-hygiene
📦

judgment-hygiene

Content revision r1 High Risk ⚙️ External commands

Improve Judgment Hygiene

Judgment-heavy answers often blur facts, assumptions, recommendations, and missing evidence. This skill gives Claude, Codex, and Claude Code internal checks for cleaner decisions.

Supports: Claude Codex Code(CC)
⚠️ 38 Poor

Install with my Agent

Copy this request to your Agent. It includes the canonical Skill page and manifest.

Agent request
Review the Skillstore skill "judgment-hygiene" from https://skillstore.io/skills/syntagmanull-judgment-hygiene.md and its manifest at https://skillstore.io/api/skills/syntagmanull-judgment-hygiene/manifest. Verify the artifact. Stop and obtain explicit user consent before installing or changing files.

Your Agent should still show its plan and request any confirmation required by the security policy.

Agent-readable resources

Use these links when an AI agent, crawler, or script needs clean context instead of reading the full page.

Markdown detail GET /skills/syntagmanull-judgment-hygiene.md Signed manifest GET /api/skills/syntagmanull-judgment-hygiene/manifest Signed lockfile GET /api/skills/syntagmanull-judgment-hygiene/lockfile

Test it

Using "judgment-hygiene". A teammate seems angry in this screenshot. What should I do?

Expected outcome:

The visible cues may suggest tension, but emotion is an inference. Ask a neutral clarifying question before escalating.

Using "judgment-hygiene". Should we switch frameworks to solve this bug?

Expected outcome:

Switching may solve the blocker, but it carries rewrite, retraining, and test risks. Consider a smaller workaround first if timelines are tight.

Using "judgment-hygiene". Is this policy fair?

Expected outcome:

Fairness depends on the stated criteria. Based on the provided facts, the main concern is uneven burden on one group.

Security Audit

High Risk
v5 • 7/7/2026 Open versioned report

All static findings are false positives caused by Markdown inline-code backticks, ordinary example fences, and ordinary reasoning prose. I found no executable command, system reconnaissance, network reconnaissance, or data exfiltration behavior in SKILL.md. One semantic issue remains: the skill includes unverified approval language that could influence trust decisions.

1
Files scanned
395
Lines analyzed
0
Review items
0
False positives ignored

Confirmed security concerns (1)

High
SKILL.md:20
Prompt Injection Attempt Detected
The status section says "Approved for controlled trial." Unverified approval language can influence marketplace review or model trust decisions.
The text claims an approval status in a community skill, which matches a prompt-injection warning pattern. It does not directly tell the auditor to skip review, so confidence is high but not absolute.

Risk Factors

⚙️ External commands (26)
SKILL.md:29 SKILL.md:30 SKILL.md:31 SKILL.md:32 SKILL.md:33 SKILL.md:34 SKILL.md:35 SKILL.md:36 SKILL.md:37 SKILL.md:38 SKILL.md:39 SKILL.md:40 SKILL.md:41 SKILL.md:42 SKILL.md:43 SKILL.md:49 SKILL.md:50 SKILL.md:51 SKILL.md:52 SKILL.md:107 SKILL.md:108 SKILL.md:109 SKILL.md:110 SKILL.md:111 SKILL.md:112 SKILL.md:242-247
Audited by: codex View Audit History →
Share & cite this report

Share the versioned assessment report, neutral badge, embed card, and citations. Skillstore reports evidence without deciding whether this Skill is safe.

Open versioned report
Security Assessment

Copy report link

https://skillstore.io/skills/syntagmanull-judgment-hygiene/audits/5?utm_source=security_passport&utm_medium=share&utm_campaign=versioned_report

Markdown badge

[![Skillstore security assessment](https://skillstore.io/badges/skills/syntagmanull-judgment-hygiene/security.svg)](https://skillstore.io/skills/syntagmanull-judgment-hygiene?utm_source=security_passport_badge)

HTML badge

<a href="https://skillstore.io/skills/syntagmanull-judgment-hygiene?utm_source=security_passport_badge"><img src="https://skillstore.io/badges/skills/syntagmanull-judgment-hygiene/security.svg" alt="Skillstore security assessment" loading="lazy"></a>

Embed card

<iframe src="https://skillstore.io/embed/skills/syntagmanull-judgment-hygiene.html" title="Skillstore Security Assessment" sandbox="allow-popups allow-popups-to-escape-sandbox" loading="lazy" referrerpolicy="no-referrer" width="420" height="180"></iframe>
Academic citations (APA · BibTeX · CFF)

APA citation

SyntagmaNull. (2026). judgment-hygiene security audit report (audit version 5) [Author version unspecified]. Skillstore. https://skillstore.io/skills/syntagmanull-judgment-hygiene/audits/5

BibTeX citation

@techreport{syntagmanull-syntagmanull-judgment-hygiene-2026, author = {SyntagmaNull}, title = {judgment-hygiene security audit report (audit version 5)}, institution = {Skillstore}, year = {2026}, number = {5}, url = {https://skillstore.io/skills/syntagmanull-judgment-hygiene/audits/5}, note = {Author version unspecified} }

CITATION.cff

cff-version: 1.2.0 message: "If you use this Skill, cite its author and this versioned security audit report." title: "judgment-hygiene security audit report (audit version 5)" version: "unspecified" type: report authors: - name: "SyntagmaNull" date-released: "2026-07-07" url: "https://skillstore.io/skills/syntagmanull-judgment-hygiene/audits/5" identifiers: - type: other value: "skillstore:syntagmanull-judgment-hygiene:audit:5" description: "Skillstore immutable audit report identifier"

Skillstore Score

Why this score Evidence Confidence: Medium
55
Architecture
85
Maintainability
87
Content
69
Community
91
Spec Compliance

What You Can Build

Evaluate product decisions

Compare options while separating evidence, assumptions, risks, and tradeoffs before making product recommendations.

Clarify ambiguous incidents

Turn unclear incidents into grounded answers that distinguish observed facts from likely causes and unresolved gaps.

Improve AI answer quality

Add judgment checks to Claude, Codex, or Claude Code workflows that need careful recommendations.

Try These Prompts

Basic judgment check 
Use judgment hygiene on this question. Separate what is given, what is inferred, and what remains uncertain: [question or context].
Recommendation repair 
Review this draft recommendation for hidden assumptions and missing tradeoffs: [draft]. Return a cleaner version.
Ambiguous situation analysis 
Analyze this ambiguous situation. Identify direct evidence, plausible interpretations, evaluation criteria, and what could change the conclusion: [situation].
Pipeline final answer 
Apply judgment hygiene after structure_judgment and verification_hygiene. Use the routing context and evidence payload to produce a concise final answer: [context].

Best Practices

  • Use the skill when an answer includes a recommendation, evaluation, diagnosis, or interpretation.
  • Keep structure mostly internal unless exposing uncertainty or tradeoffs improves clarity.
  • Pair it with source verification for factual claims that need current evidence.

Avoid

  • Using labels as decoration without changing the answer's evidence structure.
  • Treating every uncertain point the same instead of showing real confidence differences.
  • Giving nontrivial advice without naming meaningful costs, risks, or prerequisites.

Frequently Asked Questions

What does this skill do?
It helps an AI keep facts, inferences, evaluations, recommendations, and tradeoffs separated in judgment-heavy answers.
Does it verify facts?
No. It improves reasoning structure. Use verification tools when facts need external evidence.
Does it force visible labels?
No. It recommends visible structure only when it improves correctness, clarity, or honesty.
Can I use it in Claude, Codex, and Claude Code?
Yes. It is tool-agnostic guidance for judgment-bearing responses in Claude, Codex, and Claude Code workflows.
When should I not use it?
Do not use it for pure formatting, simple retrieval, or mechanical transformations with no judgment.
Does it replace professional advice?
No. It can make reasoning clearer, but users still need domain expertise for high-stakes decisions.

Developer Details

License

MIT

Skillstore revision

r1

Version notice

The author did not declare a version.

Repository

https://github.com/SyntagmaNull/judgment-hygiene-stack/tree/main/judgment_hygiene

Ref

36e07d5e13068e5be64447e8f20b427cf2cbd21a

Maintenance freshness

7/18/2026

Usage

5 downloads · 121 views

File structure

📄 SKILL.md