📦
История аудитов
mulerouter - 6 аудиты
Сравнение версий
Изменения возможностей и находок между проверенными версиями, сначала новые.
| Версия | Дата | Результат | Пункты проверки | Изменение к предыдущей |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| v6 Последняя | 5 июл. 2026 г., 20:43 | 1 подтверждено | 0 | Возможности не изменились |
| v5 | 5 июл. 2026 г., 20:43 | 1 подтверждено | 0 | Возможности не изменились |
| v4 | 30 июн. 2026 г., 11:36 | 3 подтверждено | 0 | Доступ к файловой системе |
| v3 | 17 янв. 2026 г., 08:07 | Подтверждённых находок нет | 0 | Возможности не изменились |
| v2 | 17 янв. 2026 г., 08:07 | Подтверждённых находок нет | 0 | Возможности не изменились |
| v1 | 12 янв. 2026 г., 12:11 | Подтверждённых находок нет | 0 | Базовая |
Версия аудита 6 Последняя
5 июл. 2026 г., 20:43
Static analysis raised many findings because this skill combines local Python execution, outbound API calls, and API credential configuration. Manual review found no prompt injection, hidden exfiltration, or arbitrary command execution; most static hits are documentation, tests, placeholders, or expected API client behavior. The remaining contextual concern is that API keys can be supplied on the command line, which may expose secrets through shell history or process inspection.
44
Просканировано файлов
4,569
Проанализировано строк
6
Пункты проверки
0
Ложные срабатывания проигнорированы
Подтверждённые проблемы безопасности (1)
Средний
API Key Can Be Passed Through Command Line
The model CLI exposes an --api-key option and passes the parsed value into configuration loading. Command-line secrets can be retained in shell history or visible to process inspection tools.
The CLI option and the handoff to load_config are directly visible. The risk is contextual because secure environment-variable use is also supported.
Факторы риска
⚡ Содержит скрипты (8)
🌐 Доступ к сети (26)
core/client.py:140 core/client.py:162 core/client.py:208 core/client.py:220 core/config.py:39 core/config.py:41 EVALUATION_OUTPUT.json:220 EVALUATION_OUTPUT.json:166 EVALUATION_OUTPUT.json:181 references/REFERENCE.md:72 references/REFERENCE.md:73 references/REFERENCE.md:83 SKILL.md:79 tests/test_client.py:76 tests/test_client.py:90 tests/test_client.py:104 tests/test_client.py:119 tests/test_config.py:17 tests/test_config.py:24 tests/test_task.py:83 tests/test_task.py:89 tests/test_task.py:90 tests/test_task.py:102 tests/test_task.py:107 tests/test_task.py:152 tests/test_task.py:158
🔑 Переменные окружения (58)
core/client.py:61 core/config.py:64 core/config.py:97 core/config.py:112 core/config.py:64 core/config.py:97 core/config.py:112 core/config.py:8 core/config.py:51 core/config.py:55 core/config.py:8 core/config.py:51 core/config.py:55 core/config.py:23 core/config.py:30 core/config.py:74 core/config.py:83 core/config.py:112 core/config.py:113 core/config.py:115 core/config.py:119 core/config.py:129 core/config.py:136 EVALUATION_OUTPUT.json:48 EVALUATION_OUTPUT.json:48 EVALUATION_OUTPUT.json:54 EVALUATION_OUTPUT.json:186 EVALUATION_OUTPUT.json:200 models/base.py:294 pyproject.toml:9 README.md:23 references/REFERENCE.md:10 references/REFERENCE.md:16 references/REFERENCE.md:59 SKILL.md:20 SKILL.md:31 SKILL.md:40 SKILL.md:84 tests/test_client.py:14 tests/test_config.py:46 tests/test_config.py:62 tests/test_config.py:72 tests/test_config.py:80 tests/test_config.py:16 tests/test_config.py:18 tests/test_config.py:23 tests/test_config.py:29 tests/test_config.py:38 tests/test_config.py:40 tests/test_config.py:41 tests/test_config.py:47 tests/test_config.py:51 tests/test_config.py:56 tests/test_config.py:63 tests/test_config.py:69 tests/test_config.py:80 tests/test_config.py:88 tests/test_config.py:97
⚙️ Внешние команды (24)
SKILL.md:17-24 SKILL.md:24-29 SKILL.md:29-32 SKILL.md:32-36 SKILL.md:36-38 SKILL.md:38-41 SKILL.md:41-43 SKILL.md:43 SKILL.md:45-47 SKILL.md:47 SKILL.md:49-55 SKILL.md:55-57 SKILL.md:57-61 SKILL.md:61-63 SKILL.md:63-68 SKILL.md:68-70 SKILL.md:70-73 SKILL.md:73-75 SKILL.md:75-78 SKILL.md:78-80 SKILL.md:80-84 SKILL.md:84 SKILL.md:85-86 SKILL.md:86-87
📁 Доступ к файловой системе (1)
Аудитор:: codex
5 июл. 2026 г., 20:43
Static analysis raised many findings because this skill combines local Python execution, outbound API calls, and API credential configuration. Manual review found no prompt injection, hidden exfiltration, or arbitrary command execution; most static hits are documentation, tests, placeholders, or expected API client behavior. The remaining contextual concern is that API keys can be supplied on the command line, which may expose secrets through shell history or process inspection.
44
Просканировано файлов
4,569
Проанализировано строк
6
Пункты проверки
0
Ложные срабатывания проигнорированы
Подтверждённые проблемы безопасности (1)
Средний
API Key Can Be Passed Through Command Line
The model CLI exposes an --api-key option and passes the parsed value into configuration loading. Command-line secrets can be retained in shell history or visible to process inspection tools.
The CLI option and the handoff to load_config are directly visible. The risk is contextual because secure environment-variable use is also supported.
Факторы риска
⚡ Содержит скрипты (8)
🌐 Доступ к сети (26)
core/client.py:140 core/client.py:162 core/client.py:208 core/client.py:220 core/config.py:39 core/config.py:41 EVALUATION_OUTPUT.json:220 EVALUATION_OUTPUT.json:166 EVALUATION_OUTPUT.json:181 references/REFERENCE.md:72 references/REFERENCE.md:73 references/REFERENCE.md:83 SKILL.md:79 tests/test_client.py:76 tests/test_client.py:90 tests/test_client.py:104 tests/test_client.py:119 tests/test_config.py:17 tests/test_config.py:24 tests/test_task.py:83 tests/test_task.py:89 tests/test_task.py:90 tests/test_task.py:102 tests/test_task.py:107 tests/test_task.py:152 tests/test_task.py:158
🔑 Переменные окружения (58)
core/client.py:61 core/config.py:64 core/config.py:97 core/config.py:112 core/config.py:64 core/config.py:97 core/config.py:112 core/config.py:8 core/config.py:51 core/config.py:55 core/config.py:8 core/config.py:51 core/config.py:55 core/config.py:23 core/config.py:30 core/config.py:74 core/config.py:83 core/config.py:112 core/config.py:113 core/config.py:115 core/config.py:119 core/config.py:129 core/config.py:136 EVALUATION_OUTPUT.json:48 EVALUATION_OUTPUT.json:48 EVALUATION_OUTPUT.json:54 EVALUATION_OUTPUT.json:186 EVALUATION_OUTPUT.json:200 models/base.py:294 pyproject.toml:9 README.md:23 references/REFERENCE.md:10 references/REFERENCE.md:16 references/REFERENCE.md:59 SKILL.md:20 SKILL.md:31 SKILL.md:40 SKILL.md:84 tests/test_client.py:14 tests/test_config.py:46 tests/test_config.py:62 tests/test_config.py:72 tests/test_config.py:80 tests/test_config.py:16 tests/test_config.py:18 tests/test_config.py:23 tests/test_config.py:29 tests/test_config.py:38 tests/test_config.py:40 tests/test_config.py:41 tests/test_config.py:47 tests/test_config.py:51 tests/test_config.py:56 tests/test_config.py:63 tests/test_config.py:69 tests/test_config.py:80 tests/test_config.py:88 tests/test_config.py:97
⚙️ Внешние команды (24)
SKILL.md:17-24 SKILL.md:24-29 SKILL.md:29-32 SKILL.md:32-36 SKILL.md:36-38 SKILL.md:38-41 SKILL.md:41-43 SKILL.md:43 SKILL.md:45-47 SKILL.md:47 SKILL.md:49-55 SKILL.md:55-57 SKILL.md:57-61 SKILL.md:61-63 SKILL.md:63-68 SKILL.md:68-70 SKILL.md:70-73 SKILL.md:73-75 SKILL.md:75-78 SKILL.md:78-80 SKILL.md:80-84 SKILL.md:84 SKILL.md:85-86 SKILL.md:86-87
📁 Доступ к файловой системе (1)
Аудитор:: codex
30 июн. 2026 г., 11:36
Static analysis reported a critical heuristic because this skill combines local Python execution, outbound network calls, and API credential access. Manual review found no evidence of malicious exfiltration or prompt injection; the confirmed risk is expected third-party API use with bearer credentials and user-supplied media prompts. Publish with clear warnings about external API transmission and local credential handling.
44
Просканировано файлов
4,569
Проанализировано строк
8
Пункты проверки
3
Ложные срабатывания проигнорированы
Подтверждённые проблемы безопасности (3)
Средний
Authenticated requests send user inputs to external APIs
The client builds an Authorization bearer header from the configured API key and sends request bodies to MuleRouter or MuleRun endpoints. This is core functionality, but users must understand that prompts, media URLs, and task data leave the local environment.
The bearer token header and HTTP request call are directly visible. The behavior is legitimate for this API skill, but it is still a real data-sharing boundary.
Средний
Environment and .env credential loading
The configuration loader imports python-dotenv, loads a provided file or current-directory .env file, and reads MULEROUTER_SITE and MULEROUTER_API_KEY. This is expected credential configuration, but it can expose credentials to the skill process.
The environment loading and API key lookup are explicit. I did not find evidence that unrelated environment variables are sent over the network.
Средний
Dynamic local module loading for model registration
The model listing workflow executes local provider package files through importlib so endpoints can register themselves. The provider list is fixed in the repository, so this is not arbitrary user-controlled import, but it is still local code execution.
The importlib exec_module call is present in the model listing script. The provider names are hardcoded rather than supplied by user input.
Статические ложные срабатывания проигнорированы (3)
Эти статические совпадения были отклонены семантической проверкой или совпадали только со схемными токенами, поэтому они показываются для прозрачности, но не влияют на оценку качества.
Низкий
Markdown command examples are not runtime command execution
Static analysis flagged many fenced code examples and inline command references as shell execution. These are documentation examples in Markdown, not code paths that execute commands automatically.
The flagged locations are Markdown documentation blocks and inline examples. No runtime shell invocation is present at those locations.
Низкий
Weak cryptography alerts are string false positives
The weak cryptographic algorithm cluster appears to match ordinary words such as description, model names, version strings, and seed parameters. I did not find cryptographic hashing, encryption, or signature code in the inspected implementation.
The cited lines contain descriptions and model parameters, not crypto APIs. No evidence of weak cryptographic usage was found in reviewed core files.
Низкий
System reconnaissance alerts map to task metadata parsing
The low system reconnaissance alerts correspond to task response fields and model listing output, not host discovery or operating system inspection. No evidence found of system inventory collection.
The inspected lines parse API task IDs and optional site configuration. They do not enumerate files, users, processes, network interfaces, or host properties.
Факторы риска
⚡ Содержит скрипты (8)
🌐 Доступ к сети (27)
core/client.py:140 core/client.py:162 core/client.py:208 core/client.py:220 core/config.py:39 core/config.py:41 EVALUATION_OUTPUT.json:220 EVALUATION_OUTPUT.json:166 EVALUATION_OUTPUT.json:181 references/REFERENCE.md:72 references/REFERENCE.md:73 references/REFERENCE.md:83 SKILL.md:79 tests/test_client.py:76 tests/test_client.py:90 tests/test_client.py:104 tests/test_client.py:119 tests/test_config.py:17 tests/test_config.py:24 tests/test_task.py:83 tests/test_task.py:83 tests/test_task.py:89 tests/test_task.py:90 tests/test_task.py:102 tests/test_task.py:107 tests/test_task.py:152 tests/test_task.py:158
🔑 Переменные окружения (64)
core/client.py:61 core/config.py:64 core/config.py:97 core/config.py:112 core/config.py:64 core/config.py:97 core/config.py:112 core/config.py:8 core/config.py:8 core/config.py:51 core/config.py:55 core/config.py:8 core/config.py:51 core/config.py:55 core/config.py:23 core/config.py:30 core/config.py:74 core/config.py:83 core/config.py:112 core/config.py:112 core/config.py:112 core/config.py:113 core/config.py:115 core/config.py:119 core/config.py:119 core/config.py:129 core/config.py:136 EVALUATION_OUTPUT.json:48 EVALUATION_OUTPUT.json:48 EVALUATION_OUTPUT.json:54 EVALUATION_OUTPUT.json:186 EVALUATION_OUTPUT.json:200 models/base.py:294 models/base.py:294 pyproject.toml:9 README.md:23 references/REFERENCE.md:10 references/REFERENCE.md:16 references/REFERENCE.md:59 SKILL.md:20 SKILL.md:20 SKILL.md:31 SKILL.md:40 SKILL.md:84 tests/test_client.py:14 tests/test_config.py:46 tests/test_config.py:62 tests/test_config.py:72 tests/test_config.py:80 tests/test_config.py:16 tests/test_config.py:18 tests/test_config.py:23 tests/test_config.py:29 tests/test_config.py:38 tests/test_config.py:40 tests/test_config.py:41 tests/test_config.py:47 tests/test_config.py:51 tests/test_config.py:56 tests/test_config.py:63 tests/test_config.py:69 tests/test_config.py:80 tests/test_config.py:88 tests/test_config.py:97
⚙️ Внешние команды (81)
README.md:16 README.md:21-24 README.md:24-28 README.md:28-37 references/MODELS.md:5 references/MODELS.md:7-19 references/MODELS.md:19-27 references/MODELS.md:27-28 references/MODELS.md:28-29 references/MODELS.md:29-35 references/MODELS.md:35-36 references/MODELS.md:36-37 references/MODELS.md:37-43 references/MODELS.md:43-44 references/MODELS.md:44-45 references/MODELS.md:45-46 references/MODELS.md:46-52 references/MODELS.md:52-53 references/MODELS.md:53-59 references/MODELS.md:59-60 references/MODELS.md:60-61 references/MODELS.md:61-65 references/MODELS.md:65-67 references/MODELS.md:67-69 references/MODELS.md:69-73 references/MODELS.md:73-84 references/MODELS.md:84-90 references/MODELS.md:90-91 references/MODELS.md:91-92 references/MODELS.md:92-93 references/MODELS.md:93-94 references/MODELS.md:94-95 references/MODELS.md:95-96 references/REFERENCE.md:9 references/REFERENCE.md:9 references/REFERENCE.md:9 references/REFERENCE.md:10 references/REFERENCE.md:14-17 references/REFERENCE.md:17-25 references/REFERENCE.md:25-26 references/REFERENCE.md:26-27 references/REFERENCE.md:27-28 references/REFERENCE.md:28-29 references/REFERENCE.md:29-30 references/REFERENCE.md:30-31 references/REFERENCE.md:31-32 references/REFERENCE.md:32-42 references/REFERENCE.md:42-48 references/REFERENCE.md:48-49 references/REFERENCE.md:49-60 references/REFERENCE.md:60-68 references/REFERENCE.md:68-75 references/REFERENCE.md:75-79 references/REFERENCE.md:79-84 SKILL.md:17-24 SKILL.md:24-29 SKILL.md:29-32 SKILL.md:32-36 SKILL.md:36-38 SKILL.md:38-41 SKILL.md:41-43 SKILL.md:43 SKILL.md:43-45 SKILL.md:45-47 SKILL.md:47 SKILL.md:47-49 SKILL.md:49-55 SKILL.md:55-57 SKILL.md:57-61 SKILL.md:61-63 SKILL.md:63-68 SKILL.md:68-70 SKILL.md:70-73 SKILL.md:73-75 SKILL.md:75-78 SKILL.md:78-80 SKILL.md:80-84 SKILL.md:84 SKILL.md:84-85 SKILL.md:85-86 SKILL.md:86-87
📁 Доступ к файловой системе (1)
Обнаруженные паттерны
Credential-backed outbound HTTP clientRepository-local dynamic imports
Аудитор:: codex
17 янв. 2026 г., 08:07
All 459 static findings are false positives. This is a legitimate AI media generation API client that uses standard patterns for configuration management (environment variables, .env files), API authentication (Bearer tokens to api.mulerouter.ai, api.mulerun.com), and plugin architecture. No credential exfiltration or malicious behavior detected.
45
Просканировано файлов
5,161
Проанализировано строк
4
Пункты проверки
0
Ложные срабатывания проигнорированы
Факторы риска
🌐 Доступ к сети (1)
🔑 Переменные окружения (1)
⚡ Содержит скрипты (1)
⚙️ Внешние команды (1)
Аудитор:: claude
17 янв. 2026 г., 08:07
All 459 static findings are false positives. This is a legitimate AI media generation API client that uses standard patterns for configuration management (environment variables, .env files), API authentication (Bearer tokens to api.mulerouter.ai, api.mulerun.com), and plugin architecture. No credential exfiltration or malicious behavior detected.
45
Просканировано файлов
5,161
Проанализировано строк
4
Пункты проверки
0
Ложные срабатывания проигнорированы
Факторы риска
🌐 Доступ к сети (1)
🔑 Переменные окружения (1)
⚡ Содержит скрипты (1)
⚙️ Внешние команды (1)
Аудитор:: claude
12 янв. 2026 г., 12:11
The static analysis findings are 100% false positives. This is a legitimate AI media generation API client that uses standard patterns for configuration management, API authentication, and plugin architecture. No malicious behavior detected.
43
Просканировано файлов
4,344
Проанализировано строк
4
Пункты проверки
0
Ложные срабатывания проигнорированы
Факторы риска
⚡ Содержит скрипты (1)
🌐 Доступ к сети (1)
🔑 Переменные окружения (1)
⚙️ Внешние команды (1)
Аудитор:: claude